Who would deliver a jobs guarantee for young people in Wales?

Alan Milburn is expected to propose a right to a job, an apprenticeship or a college place. In Wales, the government that sets the benefit rules is different from the one responsible for colleges, skills and health services.

If a 19-year-old in Wales is promised an apprenticeship, who has to find them a place? And if the bus timetable, a health condition or a lack of local vacancies makes an offer impossible to take up, who decides what happens to their Universal Credit?

Those questions will face ministers in Cardiff Bay and Westminster when Alan Milburn presents his independent review of young people and work, expected on Tuesday 17 November. Around one in seven young people in Wales is outside education, employment or training. The review could change what help they can expect and what the benefits system expects of them in return.

According to The Times, Milburn will propose a legal guarantee of a job, apprenticeship or college place, with potential benefit reductions for people who decline an offer. The Financial Times reports that he will also recommend a £1 billion National Insurance tax break to encourage employers to recruit young workers. These are advance accounts of the recommendations. UK ministers have said they will publish their response in due course.

What the figures tell us about Wales

The Welsh Government estimates that 14.6% of 16–24-year-olds in Wales were outside education, employment or training in the year to June 2026. The survey estimate was half a percentage point lower than a year earlier, although statisticians advise caution about small changes. The headline figures cover young people up to their 25th birthday.

Disability makes a substantial difference. Across the three years to June 2026, 39.1% of disabled 19–24-year-olds in Wales were outside work, education or training. That makes access to health care, accessible training and support in the workplace central to the Welsh response. Someone waiting for treatment and someone ready to start a job on Monday can appear in the same statistic while needing quite different help.

What does it cost the Treasury?

Milburn’s interim review estimated that £4.4 billion in the main benefits it examined went to 16–24-year-olds outside work, education or training in 2024/25. For scale, that is roughly £1.32 in every £100 of the £334.3 billion in UK social security spending recorded by the Treasury that year. The review does not give a separate Welsh figure.

Some of that money would continue to be paid if a young person found work. Personal Independence Payment, for example, helps cover the extra costs of disability and can be claimed by someone in a job. The review’s estimate of £3.2 billion in potentially avoidable spending assumes everyone in the group could move into work and earn enough to come off Universal Credit. That assumption matters when ministers discuss how much could be used to fund jobs or training.

Where Westminster’s powers meet Wales’s

Westminster sets Universal Credit rules, including the conditions attached to a claim. The Department for Work and Pensions runs Jobcentres in Wales. Welsh ministers are responsible for education, apprenticeships, careers advice and NHS services. Employment support itself straddles the boundary. Westminster holds the legislative power, while Welsh ministers can run programmes for particular groups, including young people. An English college guarantee would therefore need a Welsh counterpart if young people here were to receive an equivalent offer.

Two schemes already show how this works. A 17-year-old who has left school in Wales can approach Working Wales for assessment for Jobs Growth Wales+, which offers training and work experience to eligible 16–19-year-olds. In September, Welsh ministers extended the programme to March 2028. A 22-year-old who has spent 18 months claiming Universal Credit and looking for work can qualify for the UK Government’s Jobs Guarantee, which funds up to 25 hours of paid work a week for six months. Young people in Merthyr Tydfil, Bridgend and Caerphilly were among the first in Wales to start those jobs.

Who pays for a wider guarantee is already a live question. In March, the two governments signed an agreement setting out how they would devolve agreed employment support funding. As recently as 10 November, the Welsh Government told the Senedd that talks were continuing over the amount, the conditions attached and how much freedom Wales would have to spend it.

When the report appears, one detail will matter particularly for Wales. If a Jobcentre expects a young person to take up a place, what duty will anyone have to make sure a suitable place exists within reach of home? Westminster can change the conditions on a benefit claim. Delivering the college course, apprenticeship or health support that makes an offer possible will also require decisions, and funding, in Wales.

Categories

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *