Scottish Parliament vote, 10 November
70–48
Motion agreed, with no abstentions
Current responsibility
Westminster
Broadcasting remains reserved
The Scottish Parliament has voted to call for broadcasting powers to be devolved to Holyrood, adding a significant new dimension to the longstanding campaign for similar powers in Wales.
On Tuesday 10 November, MSPs backed a Scottish Government motion calling on the UK Government to transfer responsibility for broadcasting to the Scottish Parliament.
The motion passed by 70 votes to 48, following a debate about proposed changes to BBC services in Scotland, the future of public service broadcasting and the accountability of broadcasters to the nations they serve.
The vote does not itself devolve broadcasting. That would require changes to the UK’s constitutional arrangements, involving Westminster.
Nevertheless, it places Scotland and Wales in a similar position: both devolved governments are seeking greater control over broadcasting decisions that currently remain largely in the hands of UK institutions.
Why Scotland has acted
The immediate trigger was the BBC’s proposal to close its linear BBC Scotland television channel and discontinue Reporting Scotland: News at Seven.
Scottish ministers argue that these decisions demonstrate the weakness of existing accountability arrangements.
Màiri McAllan, Scotland’s Cabinet Secretary for Education, Culture and Gaelic, told MSPs that broadcasting decisions affect Scottish cultural identity, journalism, employment and democratic accountability.
The motion also called for stronger Gaelic-language broadcasting, greater Scottish involvement in the BBC Charter Review and the reinvestment of Scottish licence-fee revenue in Scotland.
Opponents questioned whether transferring broadcasting powers would address the underlying financial challenges facing the BBC. Scottish Labour argued for a stronger Scottish role in BBC governance and charter renewal rather than full devolution.
Wales has been making the same argument for years
The campaign for broadcasting devolution in Wales predates yesterday’s Scottish vote.
In 2022, the Welsh Government and Plaid Cymru established an expert panel to examine how broadcasting and communications powers might be devolved.
Its remit included strengthening Welsh democracy, addressing gaps in Welsh news provision, improving media plurality and protecting Welsh-language services.
The subsequent Independent Commission on the Constitutional Future of Wales also examined broadcasting devolution, including the benefits, costs and practical challenges of different models.
The most significant recent development came in July 2026, when the Welsh Government announced plans for a Shadow Broadcasting and Communications Authority for Wales.
The proposed body would develop expertise, strengthen Wales’s influence over broadcasting decisions and help establish the foundations for potential devolution.
However, it would not initially possess the statutory regulatory powers currently exercised at UK level.
In a Senedd statement on 3 November, Culture Minister Heledd Fychan confirmed that recruitment for an advisory working group would begin this month, with its first meeting planned for early 2027.
The Welsh Government is therefore pursuing a phased approach, developing institutions and policy capacity before any formal transfer of powers.
What does Scotland’s vote change for Wales?
The immediate legal position is unchanged. But politically, the vote has three important implications.
First, broadcasting devolution is no longer solely a Welsh demand. Both the Scottish and Welsh Governments are now explicitly seeking powers currently held by Westminster.
Second, the two governments have a common interest in the BBC Charter Review. Decisions about the BBC’s governance, funding and accountability could provide an opportunity to negotiate a stronger formal role for devolved institutions.
Third, the Scottish debate strengthens the argument that broadcasting is not simply an entertainment or cultural issue. Both governments are connecting it to democracy, national identity, language, journalism and economic development.
There is, however, an important difference in approach. Scotland has voted for a direct transfer of responsibility, while Wales is currently developing a shadow authority as a step towards devolution.
What could broadcasting devolution mean in practice?
| Area | Potential implications for Wales |
|---|---|
| BBC Wales | Greater Welsh involvement in decisions about services, investment, accountability and programming |
| S4C | More direct Welsh oversight of a broadcaster central to Welsh-language policy |
| Commercial television | A stronger role in decisions affecting ITV Wales and public service obligations |
| Radio | Greater influence over Welsh-language, national and local radio provision |
| Local journalism | Potential Welsh oversight of public-interest media support and measures to address news gaps |
| Creative industries | Closer alignment between broadcasting investment, commissioning and Welsh economic policy |
These are possible outcomes, not powers that Wales has already secured. Their scope would depend on the legislation, funding arrangements and regulatory model agreed.
The biggest issue: who pays?
Broadcasting devolution raises significant financial questions.
Wales currently benefits from UK-wide funding and institutions, particularly the BBC and licence-fee arrangements.
The 2024 constitutional commission’s broadcasting subgroup warned that Wales was a net beneficiary of the licence fee and that separating broadcasting structures could have financial consequences.
That means devolution would need to address whether Wales would receive an appropriate share of existing UK broadcasting resources, how BBC services would be funded and whether a Welsh regulator would duplicate existing Ofcom functions.
There is also a distinction between devolving accountability and devolving full financial responsibility. Wales could potentially gain greater powers over governance and oversight while retaining shared UK funding arrangements.
The constitutional commission considered collaborative models of this kind, alongside more extensive devolution.
Why public-interest journalism matters
For Wales, broadcasting devolution is closely connected to a wider problem: the availability of reliable news about Welsh public affairs.
Decisions about health, education, housing, transport and local government are made in Wales, yet audiences often consume media produced primarily for a UK-wide or English audience.
A Welsh broadcasting and communications authority could potentially help coordinate support for public-interest journalism, encourage plurality and strengthen coverage of devolved institutions.
That was an explicit part of the remit of Wales’s original broadcasting expert panel.
But there is an important question about how far a broadcasting authority should extend into digital journalism, online news and other media outside traditional television and radio.
For public interest news platforms like Talking Wales, this is particularly relevant. The debate is not just about who controls the BBC or S4C, but whether Wales has the institutions, resources and accountability needed to sustain a healthy national and local news environment.
What happens next?
The next steps are different in each country.
In Scotland, the parliamentary vote establishes a formal demand for devolution but does not oblige the UK Government to agree.
In Wales, the Government intends to recruit its shadow authority working group during November, with its first meeting expected early in 2027.
Both governments will also be seeking influence over the BBC Charter Review.
The crucial unanswered question is whether the UK Government is prepared to negotiate a transfer of powers or offer a stronger shared-governance arrangement.
The central question for Wales
Scotland’s vote gives renewed prominence to a debate that has been developing in Wales for years.
The arguments for reform focus on democratic accountability, the protection of national languages, the sustainability of journalism and the ability of devolved governments to influence decisions affecting their own communities.
The arguments against full devolution focus on funding, the independence of broadcasters, the complexity of splitting UK-wide institutions and the benefits of maintaining shared services.
The challenge is to determine which model would improve services and accountability without weakening the financial or editorial independence of public service broadcasting.
Holyrood’s decision does not bring broadcasting devolution to Wales any closer in legal terms. But it creates an opportunity for the Welsh and Scottish Governments to pursue a common approach to Westminster, particularly during the BBC Charter Review.